What makes a great leader in the workplace?

26 September, 2023

Written by Josie Truscott, C.Psychol Forensic & Occupational, HCPC Registered, Head of Talent Identification

When you hear the phrase ‘great leader,’ who comes to mind? Is it the best boss you worked with throughout your career? Was it a teammate or coach you interacted with while playing organised sports? Or perhaps a friend or family member who left an indelible impression on you?

No matter who you picture, the reality is that we have all interacted with leaders – some with a formal title and some who just embodied the role naturally. And while those experiences are all unique, there are a number of important and consistent qualities that leaders should possess.

When it comes to the world of talent management, whom you select or promote into leadership roles plays a pivotal part in moving your organisation forward. I’ve compiled a number of quotes about leadership that resonated with me and convey the importance of assessing for those critical competencies that will ensure they are remembered as an effective and capable – and even a ‘great’ – leader.

“Leadership cannot just go along to get along. Leadership must meet the moral challenge of the day.” — Jesse Jackson

In today’s fast-paced and complex business world, effective leadership is more critical than ever. Leaders must inspire, guide, and empower their teams, to ‘meet the moral challenge of the day’ – and for leaders in the 21st century, there are many moral challenges. To do this successfully, leaders need a deep understanding of themselves and their team members. This is where insightful leadership comes into play.

“There are three essentials to leadership: humility, clarity, and courage.” — Fuchan Yuan

Insightful leadership goes beyond traditional leadership approaches. It is characterised by a leader’s ability to understand their own strengths and challenges, and those of their teams. Such leaders are self-aware, empathetic, and open to feedback. They recognise that people are not ‘one-size-fits-all’ and strive to adapt their leadership style to suit the unique needs of their diverse team.

“Leaders aren’t born, they are made. And they are made just like anything else, through hard work.” — Vince Lombardi

There is a wealth of research that illustrates the cost of a bad hire, including reputation and financial impacts, only amplifying the importance of organisations ensuring that they select the right people. This starts as early as recruitment and continues through to promotion, succession planning, and development as leaders.

“The quality of a leader is reflected in the standards they set for themselves.” — Ray Kroc

One of the cornerstones of leadership is self-awareness. Leaders who understand their own personality traits, values, and cognitive abilities are better equipped to make informed decisions, manage their emotions, and build strong relationships with their team members. This self-awareness helps leaders to leverage their strengths and work on their challenges. Furthermore, insight into the drivers and motivators of leaders gives a clear indication of the culture they are likely to establish.

“The first responsibility of a leader is to define reality. The last is to say thank you. In between, the leader is a servant.” — Max De Pree

Creating purpose and motivating teams around a compelling vision are core expectations of leadership. Time and again, research into leadership highlights the importance of setting a direction. But, to go back to Rev. Jackson’s point about moral challenge, there have been some recent powerful examples of leaders who have rallied followers around morally dubious visions and realities. Robust, evidence-based assessment offers a route to identify the potential leaders whose motivators and drivers are likely to risk serious damage to people and organisations.

“Great leaders are almost always great simplifiers.” — General Colin Powell

Successful leaders are able to read their team members and understand that a cohesive and harmonious team is more productive and innovative. Keith Grint’s work on ‘wicked issues’ further highlights the necessity of a cognitively diverse team bringing a range of views, experiences, and knowledge.

By promoting better communication, leaders can foster a more positive and collaborative work environment. Measuring the adaptability of leaders and their readiness to create an environment in which everyone feels safe to voice their views is critical to establish a culture of inclusion and psychological safety.

“A leader takes people where they want to go. A great leader takes people where they don’t necessarily want to go, but ought to be.” — Rosalynn Carter

Like any journey, a reliable roadmap ensures that you will get where you need to go, and the same goes for personal and professional development. Leaders should have personalised development plans for themselves and their team members. In addition, firms can use the insight offered by rich, in-depth assessments for on-boarding programmes, targeted development initiatives around common themes, and identifying roles that will play to individuals’ strengths.

“Earn your leadership every day.” — Michael Jordan

Leadership is not just about short-term wins; it’s about achieving sustained success for the organisation and its people. Leaders who are better equipped to make decisions that contribute to long-term growth and stability can identify and nurture future leaders within their teams, ensuring a legacy of effective leadership.

How to select the best leaders for your organisation

If you want to ensure that you have the best leaders in the roles that steer the direction of your organisation, leadership assessments are an effective way to measure for necessary competencies needed for success in the position. And while there are many leadership assessments to choose from, there are a number of features that your organisation should be sure are addressed:

  • Measure emotional intelligence (EI) EI is a critical component for successful leaders and leadership assessments should be validated tools that provide an understanding and awareness of the influence of mindset and emotions on behaviour.
  • Focus on people – People are at the heart of this entire process, so you’ll want to ensure transparency in your approach and provide participants with a fair opportunity to prepare. During the assessment, use exercises that are designed to create a positive participant experience. To continue the journey, all leaders should receive personalised feedback and development planning support to create a well-rounded, development-focused experience. Furthermore, this should be aligned with other organisational development programmes.
  • Assess fairly, inclusively, and objectively – Using a robust and consistent process helps provide a clear picture of performance, ensuring all participants are assessed fairly and reliably.

As the quotes listed above describe, being a leader isn’t a passive position; it’s being an active participant every single day. Investing in your current and future leaders has a direct impact on your company’s morale, finances, and sustainability. Because of that, it is critical to utilise the right tools that measure the most relevant competencies and provide the necessary data to move your workforce forward.

What is the true cost of hiring poor leadership?

Choosing the wrong leaders, be it through hiring or promotion, has significant financial and reputational implications. Forbes states that the cost of a poor leadership hire can vary from £30,165 to over £132,000, depending on salary and industry factors.

With our extensive experience partnering with the world’s leading organisations and ongoing research into the evolving landscape of leadership, we’ve gained profound insights into the critical leadership behaviours that drive organisational success. Discover how we can equip you to make well-informed choices throughout your selection, development, and promotion processes.

Learn more
Decoration
Share